Ever hated a song, then put it on repeat?
The first time you hear it, the chorus sounds like someone lost a bet. The second time, it’s playing while you buy toothpaste. By Friday, you’re singing along in the car.
Then the song ends. You play it again. There’s nobody around to blame.
That little reversal is a good way into why familiarity increases liking. Psychologists call it the mere exposure effect: seeing or hearing something repeatedly can make you feel more positively about it. In experiments, people can come to prefer images they’ve seen several times over similar images they’ve seen less often. Simply seeing the images more can change how people rate them.
One possible explanation is that familiar things are easier to take in. On the first listen, you’re still figuring out where the melody is going. A few plays later, you know the drums will drop out just before the chorus. Now you get to enjoy the pause.
That’s one way to explain the shift. A major review found that existing explanations still leave some of the evidence unexplained. The chorus may also have caught you in a better mood, or you may have finally noticed the bass line. Real life rarely gives you the courtesy of changing one thing at a time.
And then there’s the insurance jingle. You know every word. You’d still pay a small fee to never hear it again.
Myth 1. “First impressions stick”

Verdict. A first impression can change, especially when you had very little to go on.
The TV character you wanted written out
Picture a sitcom set in an office. Halfway through the pilot, a character interrupts a staff meeting to ask who moved the communal mustard. He’s painfully earnest about it. You decide he’s the price you’ll pay for enjoying the rest of the show.
By episode five, he walks into the meeting carrying a label maker. You laugh before he opens his mouth.
By episode eight, he’s out sick. You spend half the episode wondering when he’ll turn up.
The character’s delivery hasn’t necessarily changed. You’ve learned how to hear it. A silence that felt awkward in the pilot now gives you just enough time to wonder how seriously he’s about to take something that matters to absolutely no one else.
Of course, the writers might have given him a great scene in the meantime. Maybe you find out that his coworkers keep stealing his lunch, and suddenly the label maker strikes you as a reasonable response. Now you have a new reason to like him. His mannerisms have grown familiar, and you understand him better. A sitcom can do both in the same scene.
What happens when all you get is another look?
Researchers Richard Moreland and Scott Beach tested a simpler version of this in a college classroom. Four women posed as students and attended different numbers of class sessions, from zero to 15. They avoided interacting with the class. At the end of the term, students saw their photos and gave more favorable ratings to women who had attended more often.
There were no shared jokes, group projects, or heroic offers of a spare pen. The students had simply had more chances to see some of the women.
If you’ve ever started nodding at someone you regularly see at the gym, you can imagine how that feels. You have no idea what they do for work or what they’re like at dinner. You know they show up at 6:15 and make the same face you do when the music is too loud. When you walk in and spot them, the room feels a little friendlier.
Some first impressions have more behind them
Think about two reactions you might have after meeting someone:
- “I couldn’t get a read on them.” You were introduced in a crowded room and exchanged about eight words. Another encounter could give you a much better sense of them.
- “They were rude to the server.” You saw a specific thing that bothered you. Another encounter could add context, or it could give you another example of the same behavior.
The first reaction tells you how little you had to work with. The second gives you something concrete to consider. Both can change, but simply seeing a person again may do more for the first impression than the second.
You could give the mustard guy a whole season and still want him to move departments. The point is that the pilot gave you one scene. A season gives you a chance to see what else he does.
Myth 2. “The more you see something, the more you’ll like it”

Verdict. A few encounters can help. More can wear out the welcome.
The first time you see the meal delivery ad, the noodles look good.
By the fourth viewing, you can identify the company from the sound of a fork hitting a plate.
By the twelfth, that fork has interrupted three cliffhangers. You’re thinking about cooking out of spite.
Why the ad gets old before you forget it
A 2017 review led by psychologist R. Matthew Montoya analyzed results from 81 articles on repeated exposure. For visual material, the findings were consistent with an upside-down U. Liking tended to rise at first, then the gains tapered and could reverse. The review found different results for audio, so it can’t tell you how many plays your favorite song has left before you start skipping it.
The noodle ad makes it easy to see why remembering something and liking it deserve separate questions:
- Do you recognize it? Instantly. You could identify that fork in a police lineup.
- Do you enjoy seeing it? You were ready for the episode to get back to the part where someone opens the safe.
- Would you buy the noodles? Possibly. It’s raining, and the fridge contains half a lemon.
Those answers can all be true at once. The company can be the first one that comes to mind when you want dinner, even if you’d happily retire its entire ad campaign.
A better question than “How many times?”
Ask what happens each time you encounter it.
If the ad comes up once while you’re browsing dinner ideas, you might welcome the suggestion. If it plays three times during the last ten minutes of a show, each viewing also means waiting longer to see what’s inside the safe. Same noodles. Different experience.
The timing matters even with things you already love. A song you choose on a run might feel perfect when it kicks in halfway up a hill. Hear it for the third time during a shift at work and you’d give anything to hear what the store sounds like in silence. A week later, you might put it back on yourself.
It also helps to ask what bothered you in the first place. Say you order a coffee that tastes fruitier than your usual. The first sip catches you off guard. By the time you’re halfway through the cup, that unfamiliar flavor might be the part you look forward to.
If what bothered you was that the coffee was lukewarm, the fifth sip has a tough assignment. It may confirm everything you learned from the first four.
That’s where the idea that “everything grows on you” falls apart. Sometimes getting used to something gives you a chance to appreciate it. Sometimes you get very familiar with the exact thing you dislike.
Myth 3. “If there’s no spark, there never will be”

Can attraction grow over time?
Yes, romantic attraction can grow over time, and getting to know someone can also lead to a warm, entirely platonic connection.
Imagine you meet Sam for coffee. They seem kind. You talk about work, the neighborhood, and the shop’s baffling decision to sell a sandwich for fourteen dollars.
You’re glad you went. You also feel no particular urge to invent a reason to text Sam before you get home.
Still, you’re curious enough to meet again. This time you go for a walk. You spend less of it wondering where to put your hands. Sam remembers the strange detail you mentioned about your sister’s wedding and asks how it turned out. Their dry sense of humor starts to land.
You miss a turn. Sam spots a bakery, suggests pastries, and makes the detour the best part of the afternoon.
On the way home, you think of something you want to tell them. This time you send the text.
Three things changed on that second date
Sam felt familiar. You already knew their voice and how they tended to pause before answering. You spent less time trying to read the room and more time listening.
You enjoyed the conversation. The wedding story became a running joke. The walk gave you things to react to together. There’s now an afternoon you’d happily do again.
You discovered qualities you liked. Sam paid attention, remembered something important to you, and handled a small change of plans without appointing a committee. You had little chance to see any of that during the first coffee.
Psychologist Harry Reis and colleagues found something related in two experiments with previously unacquainted people. Participants who interacted longer reported greater interpersonal attraction. Feeling heard, feeling comfortable, and feeling that they knew the other person better helped explain the pattern. The studies paired same-sex strangers and measured general interpersonal attraction, so they tell us more about how people come to like each other than about whether a second date will produce a spark.
Liking someone more can go a few ways
Imagine a third date. You’re sitting next to Sam, they lean in to show you something on their phone, and you find yourself wishing they’d stay that close. That’s a different feeling from being relieved there’s finally someone you can send the wedding photos to.
Or imagine you look forward to the next walk and feel entirely satisfied when it ends with a wave. You like Sam more than you did after coffee. You might have made a friend.
The opposite can happen, too. You can feel a spark over coffee and later realize that Sam rarely asks you a follow-up question, or that you have very different ideas of what a good weekend looks like. Time gives you more to go on in either direction.
That’s why a flat first date can mean different things. Maybe you were both exhausted and spent twenty minutes establishing where you grew up, a topic neither of you has thought about since filling out a form. Maybe you had a lovely evening and felt no desire to do it again. If you’re genuinely curious how it might feel in a different setting, another date can give you an answer. If you already know how you feel, that answer counts too.
Back to the song you swore you hated
The next time it comes on, listen for the part you used to skip. Maybe it was the chorus. Maybe it was the half-second pause before it, when you thought the song had finally finished and it turned out to have another minute left.
Now you know what’s coming. You might still reach for the skip button. Or you might find yourself turning the volume up just in time for the drums to come back in.
And if you’ve been parked outside your house for forty seconds because the song you supposedly hate still has one good part left, go ahead and finish it. You can get out of the car after the chorus.
Other Articles:
Why Online Communities Develop Their Own Rules
7 Lowball Technique Examples You’ll Recognize Instantly
Why You Still Cringe at Something Everyone Else Forgot
Spot These Types of Social Influence Before Your Next Big Decision
Why Healthy Love Can Feel Unfamiliar






Leave a Reply